Curing South Africa’s “Sea Blindness” – Cyril Ramaphosa, SONA and the Indian Ocean Rim Association

Graham Dominy writes that Ramaphosa should order his diplomats to declassify the IORA strategy.

South Africa got its new Valentine shortly before the clock ticked to midnight on 14th February 2018, as Jacob Zuma exited and Cyril Ramaphosa became first, acting President, then President-Elect and finally President of the Republic in less than twenty-four hours.

Read More…

Not a position for a Gentleman

Sir Matthew Nathan as Colonial Administrator: From Cape Coast Castle to Dublin Castle via Natal

This article examines the role of Sir Matthew Nathan, British permanent under secretary for Ireland at the time of the Easter Rising in April 1916, and how critical events in his career as soldier, colonial governor and civil servant shaped his conduct and reaction to events in Ireland as the Rising unfolded around him. The article raises issues of identities: namely Nathan’s own identity as an English gentleman, when, given his Jewish background, he was an outsider to that caste. Nathan’s brief military career and lengthier career as a colonial governor earned him high praise as a model bureaucrat. In this paper Nathan’s track from the War Office through government houses situated in West Africa, Hong Kong and Natal to Dublin Castle is traced to illustrate the changes in his character from decisiveness to indecision. While Nathan clearly misread the volatile situation in Ireland over the 1916 Easter weekend, his actions demonstrated both indecision and bureaucratic delaying tactics. It is argued that his experiences with obdurate settler ministers in Natal played a role in shaping his hesitancy at the time of crisis in Dublin and that this hesitancy provided an opportunity for the direct action of the Irish Volunteers. The conclusion is that, at the time of the Irish crisis, Nathan failed to exercise the “power of the personal influence” expected of an experienced governor.

Read More…

Limitations On Liberalism: A Tale Of Three Schreiners

I am greatly honoured to have been invited to present the 2017 Alan Paton Memorial Lecture at my Alma Mater and in a venue that brings back so many memories of my student days.

The newly published Volume 2 of Bill Guest’s history of the University of Natal contains two episodes from the early 1970s which occurred in this hall. They both have a slight bearing on the topic of this lecture. There was a Rag Variety concert held on this stage where Michael Lambert composed the lyrics parodying Gilbert and Sullivan’s operettas, particularly The Mikado. He lampooned three major campus personalities of the day: Professors Colin Webb, Colin Gardner and Deneys Schreiner: “a giggling tall historian, an English Pwof who lisps and a bearded scientist”; an indication that there was a liberal tolerance of criticism of the university by students.

Read More…

The first Jewish governor in the British Empire, Sir Matthew Nathan: an “outsider” in Africa and Ireland

The first Jewish governor in the British Empire, Sir Matthew Nathan; an “outsider in Africa and Ireland”. Jewish Historical Studies: Transactions of the Jewish Historical Society of England, 49 (1), December 2017, pp 162-187. doi: 10.14324/111.444.jhs.2017v49.049

https://www.scienceopen.com/document?vid=de47f0cd-9069-4573-a9a8-a2c5a267c390

Changing meanings: The Ghanaian memorial stool of the KwaZulu-Natal Museum

This article examines the historical context in which the so-called “Ashanti Golden Stool” was acquired as an iconic artefact for the new Natal Museum in the first decade of the 20th century, the heyday of imperialism.

The multi-layered symbolism surrounding the stool and the importance of chiefly stools as symbols of authority in Ghana are explored. The role of the donor, Sir Matthew Nathan, governor of Natal and former governor of the Gold Coast (Ghana), in obtaining the stool and the West African collection for the museum is discussed in the context of inter-colonial imperialism. The history of the memorial stool provides a case study for historians examining artefacts of material culture as sources of historical knowledge.

Read More…

The effects of an administrative and policy vacuum on access to archives in South Africa

Open access to information is an essential tool for combating inefficiency in the machinery of state and for the assertion of human rights.

Access to archives is essential for ensuring long-term accountability and the learning of lessons from past events and past errors. Despite the constitutional and administrative importance of open access to archives, the sector is largely ignored in South African government policy formulation, although in-depth information and extensive recommendations are available on the subject, beginning with recommendations made by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in 1998. This article focuses on a report entitled State of the Archives: An analysis of South Africa’s national archival system, 2014, and contrasts this document with the almost complete neglect of the National Archives in the Draft White Paper on Arts, Culture and Heritage published for comment in November 2016 and more recently in mid-2017. It is argued that one of the State of the Archives weaknesses is that it looks at the “national archival system” and especially the National Archives of South Africa, in and of itself, while insufficient attention is paid to the National Archives as a functioning component within the greater bureaucratic machinery. It is further argued that there is a close correlation between the state of a National Archives and the state of a national government bureaucracy. In this context, a repositioning of archives to align the sector better in terms of the objectives of the National Development Plan and the exercise of constitutional rights is recommended.

Read More…

Campus of Storms: Freedom of Expression versus post-colonial cringe at UCT

Student protest movements have risen up across South African campuses focussing on issues of transformation, as well as issues of funding, in the higher education sector.

One of the more controversial moments in the movement’s history was the burning of paintings during a protest at UCT in early 2016. Graeme (sic) Dominy looks at the challenges this poses to freedom of expression and the South African art world against the backdrop of rising nationalist sentiments.

Read More…

Book Review by Blake Duffield, Journal of Military History: April 2017

Blake Duffield, of the Central Baptist College, Conway, Arkansas, reviewed Graham’s book, Last Outpost on the Zulu Frontier in the Journal of Military History.

In spite of its humble origins as an “obscure frontier post” (p. xv), the imperial garrison stationed at Fort Napier, situated around the city of Pietermaritzburg in the Colony of Natal, served a more significant role than merely defending Britain’s imperial periphery in southern Africa, according to Graham Dominy. He contends that, as the site of the single longest British occupation of any place on the African continent, the garrison fundamentally shaped the social, political, and economic nature of settler society in and around Natal for more than seven decades. At the heart of Dominy’s analysis lies a central assumption about the nature of the British army – namely, that this institution both “reflected and magnified” (p. 22) Britain’s deeply ingrained values of class hierarchy, paternalism, and masculinity. These values, Dominy maintains, gradually seeped into the settler community as a result of close and persistent contact with the outpost.

Read More…

“On the side of the angels”: Helen Suzman and the 1966 Robert Kennedy tour

This Brief done by the HSF’s Research Fellow Graham Dominy discusses Helen Suzman the 1966 Robert Kennedy Tour.

1966 was a bleak year in South African politics. The National Party Government celebrated the fifth anniversary of the white republic and won its biggest ever majority in the all-white elections in March. The ANC, the SACP, the PAC and their allies were all banned and their leadership was either in exile or in jail. In the Eastern Cape, Verwoerd’s theories of grand apartheid were being test-driven in the nominally autonomous Transkei Bantustan. North of the Limpopo, Ian Smith had recently proclaimed UDI for ‘Rhodesia’ and growled defiance at the world. The Salazar dictatorship in Portugal was still reasonably strong and still ruling Angola and Mozambique. There was apparent substance in the rhetoric of a great white ‘anti-communist’ redoubt in Southern Africa anchored by a powerful white South Africa.

Read More…

She saved Natal in 1842

From “Man O’ War” to historian’s desk. The strange fate of the timbers of HMS Southampton.

A recent episode of the popular TV programme, “The Antiques Roadshow“, shown on South Africa’s main satellite television channel, featured a curious item that piqued my interest. It was a wooden column, made from a large baulk of timber from Admiral Nelson’s famous flagship, HMS Victory. The show’s expert remarked that about a century ago, the manufacture of furniture and mementoes from the timber of scrapped and obsolete warships was very popular and initiated a fashion which spread across the then British Empire.

Read More…